Apocalypse Championship

2012 Stitches

2011 Karnage

2010 Joey Staplez

2009 Rocko

2008 Kevin Kaos

2007 F-O

2006 Major Morpheus Morency

NOTE: Months later, it was revealed that the masked referee who called for the submission when it appeared that Karnage was only reached for the ropes, was Captain Vincent Zarrello under the mask. As a result of this, Moody Starr would strip Major Morpheus Morency of the 2006 Apocalypse Championship on May 12, 2007.

2004 Captain Amazing (Captain Vincent Zarrello)

2003 F-O

2002 The Jersey Devil